Do you belong?

4 minutes

Last Thursday, Google announced a new Howard University campus at its headquarters in Mountain View, California. Howard is a private, historically Black university in Washington, DC whose alumni include Stokely Carmichael, Thurgood Marshall and Ta-Nehisi Coates. Dubbed “Howard West,” the campus is part of Google’s continued effort to attract and retain Black software engineers.

It’s an important step forward, and not just because of the symbolic connection to one of the nation’s most respected HBCUs. What I’m hoping for is more collisions between cultures. The dearth of Black software engineers in Silicon Valley isn’t simply a numbers issue (a leaky pipeline, as it were). It also reflects the cultural and geographic separation of demographics.

Two of the most effective ways to break down cultural barriers in the workplace are storytelling and the intentional formation of social bonds. Storytelling, in this context, is an invitation for everyone, regardless of job title, to share personal and candid stories about how they experience the world. In my lectures and workshops, sharing my story reliably leads others to feel empowered to share theirs. Social bonds form when employees realize that the differences dividing them are at once trivial and interesting, once the air is cleared. We can all relate to feelings of discrimination and marginalization if we make the space to understand and be understood.

So what’s next?

I’m preparing for a few weeks of travel, and the theme of my speaking engagements is belonging. One might argue that it’s simply the latest term to inch us closer to acknowledging the suffocating effects of structural racism and the systematic, historical discrimination that marginalized groups experience day in and day out.

Let’s review.

Organizations became interested in diversity in the late nineties and early two thousands, when financial companies were rocked by enormous discrimination lawsuits. Sex and race discrimination settlements in the hundreds of millions forced companies to institute programs to protect their bottom line. Not exactly a warm and fuzzy moral imperative, but it got the ball rolling.

As diversity programs merged with social progress, organizations and the people who stood to benefit started looking more closely at what was and wasn’t working. The term “inclusion” grew out of this, and it’s increasingly lumped into conversations about diversity. They aren’t the same. If diversity is about representation, inclusion accounts for the subjective, lived experiences of the people who make up that diversity. As Vernā Myers puts it, diversity is being invited to the party, and inclusion is being asked to dance.

Inclusion isn’t as easy to measure, because it isn’t a simple matter of headcount. This is where diversity slogans and taglines begin to ring hollow for many organizations: seeing it through takes courage. It’s why the technology industry has spent the past two years investing in diversity programs that don’t work. They’re safe, socially acceptable, minimize discomfort, and let leadership separate themselves from the results.

Belonging is the idea that a person, and everything that makes up their humanity, is acknowledged. Many organizations try to minimize the idea that difference exists in the workplace, to their continued peril. Not only does that not work in places like New York City, it runs counter to the research. Scholars studying social belonging at the University of Colorado in 2007 found that normalizing concerns about belonging can be productive. I’d argue it’s essential.

Tech companies have been recruiting at HBCUs for years without much to show for it. There are many reasons, but the one you’ll hear from Black folks pursuing these jobs is feeling “othered” in their interactions and experiences. Microsoft found in the nineties that if you provide enough onsite comforts, engineers will spend most of their waking hours at work. Today’s leading tech companies invest heavily in comforts like yoga classes, rock climbing walls and massages, without realizing that tens of thousands of potential employees may have precisely no interest in any of them.

“She wasn’t a good culture fit” then stands in for what could just as easily be “it was clear that she found the artificial reality we’ve built for 25-year-old white men a bit strange, and devoid of signals that she’d find a home here,” or simply, “She didn’t feel like she belonged here.”

The truth is available if we seek it out, but it takes courage. If you were the VP of HR at a multinational tech company, would you commission a study likely to surface clear evidence that your organization’s best efforts do more to widen disparities in tech than to shrink them? If you answered yes, you probably wouldn’t have that job in the first place, or keep it for long after commissioning the study.

That’s unfortunate, because the data clearly shows that people from different backgrounds experience diversity and inclusion programs differently, and define the terms differently. Worse, poorly implemented diversity programs have been shown to activate bias and incite backlash. That suggests doing nothing is better than doing it poorly, but doing nothing is no longer an option.

Diversity. Inclusion. Othering. Belonging. It’s a lot to keep up with, and even harder to engage with meaningfully. But this is the work, and there has never been a better time for organizations to step up and lead.

Enjoyed this? Subscribe for updates.

No spam, ever. New posts & occasional updates.